top of page
Caroline's Cookies Cookie Flavors

PAST FLAVORS

Caroline's Cookies Website Assets.png
Caroline's Cookies Cookie Flavors

PAST FLAVORS

Caroline's Cookies Brownie Sandwich

Two brownie cookies sandwiched together with chocolate chip cookie dough frosting.

Brownie Sandwich

Caroline's Cookies Key Lime Pie Cookie

A lime and graham cracker based cookie rolled in graham crackers and topped with a key lime pie filling and a dollop of whipped cream.

Key Lime Pie

Caroline's Cookies Banana Pudding Cookie

A banana cookie rolled in Nilla wafers with a banana pudding topping!

Banana Pudding

Caroline's Cookies Chocolate Cake

A mega gooey chocolate cake cookie piped with a Chocolate buttercream and rainbow sprinkles!

Chocolate Cake

Caroline's Cookies Churro Cookie

Cinnamon cookie rolled in cinnamon sugar, a brown sugar cinnamon frosting, and a dipping sauce of your choice: chocolate or caramel!

Churro

Caroline's Cookies Toffee Cake

Chocolate cookie with Heath toffee bits topped with house made toffee syrup, condensed milk, and whipped cream!

Toffee Cake

Caroline's Cookies Lemon Meringue

A lemon cookie rolled in graham cracker crust and topped with house made lemon curd & toasted meringue 

Lemon Meringue

Caroline's Cookies Snickerdoodle Nutella

A snickerdoodle cookie stuffed with a Nutella center, rolled in cinnamon sugar, and topped with a Nutella frosting

Snickerdoodle Nutella

Caroline's Cookies Chocolate Pistachio

A browned butter cookie with pistachios and dark chocolate chunks

Chocolate Pistachio

An ooey gooey butter cookie dusted with powdered sugar

Ooey Gooey

Caroline's Cookies Chocolate Strawberry Cookie

A naturally flavored strawberry cookie with semi sweet chocolate chips and a chocolate drizzle on top

Chocolate Strawberry

Caroline's Cookies Buddy's Cookie

Based off Buddy The Elf's spaghetti! Sugar cookie with snowcaps, marshmallows, white chocolate covered lo mein noodles, mini M&M's, & chocolate syrup!

Buddy's Cookie

Caroline's Cookies Stuffed Chocolate Chip

Our classic chocolate chip cookie stuffed and topped with Christmas Pillsbury sugar cookies!

Stuffed Chocolate Chip

Caroline's Cookies Eggnog

An eggnog inspired cookie with hints of cinnamon, nutmeg, and eggnog. Topped with an eggnog cream cheese frosting!

Eggnog

Caroline's Cookies Banana Bread Cookie

A banana cookie with cinnamon, walnuts, & mini semi-sweet chocolate chips. Topped with a crunchy cinnamon streusel and a drizzle of icing!

Banana Bread

Caroline's Cookies Turtle Cookie

A brownie cookie stuffed with a house-made caramel rolled in crushed up pecans!

Turtle

Caroline's Cookies Blackout Cookie

Deep chocolate cookie with Hershey's Cookies & Cream bars mixed throughout and a crunchy white chocolate cookies & cream topping

Blackout

Caroline's Cookies Pumpkin Sandwich Cookie

2 browned butter pumpkin snickerdoodle cookies sandwiched together with a caramel cream cheese frosting

Pumpkin Sandwich

Caroline's Cookies Oatmeal Cream Pie

Inspired by the classic! 2 soft oatmeal cookies sandwiched together with a cream center!

Oatmeal Cream Pie

Peanut Butter Oreo

Classic dough with peanut butter Oreos, rolled in peanut butter Oreos, topped with chocolate Oreo frosting & a swirl of peanut butter frosting

Peanut Butter Oreo

Caroline's Cookies Half Baked Cookie

1/2 brownie 1/2 chocolate chip cookie with chocolate caramel cups. Topped with cookie dough, caramel cups, & a caramel drizzle!

Half Baked

Caroline's Cookies Birthday Sandwich Cookie

2 Funfetti birthday cake cookies with white chocolate chips sandwiched together with birthday cake frosting 

Birthday Sandwich

Caroline's Cookies Chocolate Pie Cookie

An Oreo chocolate based cookie topped with a chocolate filling and fresh whipped cream

Chocolate Pie

Caroline's Cookies Blueberry Lemon Cookie

Lemon & blueberry cookie with blueberries mixed in and topped with a blueberry lemon glaze!

Blueberry Lemon

Caroline's Cookies Cornbread Sanwich Cookie

Cornbread cookie drizzled with honey & topped with honey buttercream (in memory of my late grandpa’s all time favorite!)

Cornbread

Caroline's Cookies S'mores Sandwich

Two Graham cracker based cookies sandwiched together with marshmallow & chocolate ganache 

S'mores Sandwich

Moose Tracks Cookie

Based off the iconic ice cream! Vanilla based cookie with swirls of chocolate fudge & peanut butter cups mixed throughout!

Moose Tracks

Chantilly Sandwich

Two almond based cookies sandwiched together with Chantilly cream and fresh berries!

Chantilly Sandwich

Caroline's Cookies Carrot Cake Cookie

Spiced carrot cake cookie fresh carrots, pecans, and a cream cheese frosting

Carrot Cake

Caroline's Cookies Double Doozie Cookie

Two M&M cookies sandwiched together with vanilla buttercream frosting

M&M Double Doozie

Caroline's Cookie Cheesecake Caramel Cookie

Cheesecake bites mixed in, homemade caramel stuffing, rolled in graham cracker crust

Caramel Cheesecake

Caroline's Cookies Stuffed Red Velvet Cookie

A soft red velvet cookie with semi-sweet chocolate chips mixed throughout & stuffed with a cream cheese center.

Stuffed Red Velvet

Caroline's Cookie Cowgirl Cookie

Oatmeal cookie with mini peanut butter chips, pecans, chocolate chips, and coconut

Cowgirl Cookie

Caroline's Cookies Pecan Cream Cheese King Cake

Our original king cake cookie topped with a pecan cream

cheese frosting and a drizzle of icing

Pecan Cream Cheese King Cake

Caroline's Cookies Blueberry Cream Cheese King Cake

Our original king cake topped with a blueberry cream cheese frosting and a drizzle of frosting

Blueberry Cream Cheese King Cake

Caroline's Cookies Cream Cheese King Cake Cookie

Our original king cake topped with a cream cheese frosting and stripes of Mardi Gras trio sprinkles

Cream Cheese King Cake

Caroline's Cookies Original King Cake Cookie

A cinnamon and almond based cookie braided together with cinnamon sugar and topped with an almond icing

Original King Cake

Caroline's Cookies Peppermint Hot Cocoa Cookie

Chocolate cookie with Andes peppermints mixed, dipped in a peppermint white chocolate coating and topped with candy cane! 

Peppermint Bark

Caroline's Cookies Hot Cocoa Cookie

A hot cocoa based cookie stuffed with a marshmallow center!

Hot Cocoa

Caroline's Cookies Gingerbread Cookie

A gingerbread spice cookie topped with a few white chocolate chips! 

Gingerbread

Caroline's Cookies Christmas Tree Cake Cookies

A sweet vanilla cookie rolled in Christmas sugar crystals and topped with a Christmas Tree Cake marshmallow frosting! 

Christmas Tree Cake

Caroline's Cookies Red Velvet Cookie

A soft red velvet cookie with semi-sweet chocolate chips mixed throughout & topped with a swirl of cream cheese frosting.

Red Velvet

Caroline's Cookies Toffee Crunch Cookie

A sweet and salty cookie with pretzels, toffee, and milk chocolate chips!

Toffee Crunch

Caroline's Cookies White Chocolate Espresso

An espresso cookie rolled in an espresso streusel. This cookie is for the coffee lovers!

Espresso Streusel 

Caroline's Cookies Cinnamon Roll

Cinnamon cookie with a brown sugar & cinnamon filling topped a with cream cheese frosting

Cinnamon Roll

Caroline's Cookies Marble Cookie

Chocolate cookie with white chocolate chips swirled together with a classic chocolate chip cookie

Marble Cookie

Caroline's Cookies Snickerdoodle Extreme Cookie

A snickerdoodle cookie stuffed with a Dulce de Leche center and topped with a light Biscoff cookie butter frosting!

Snickerdoodle Extreme

Caroline's Cookies Chocolate Peanutbutter Cookie

An all new fudge chocolate cookie with semi-sweet chocolate chips, a peanut butter topping, and a drizzle of chocolate!

Chocolate Peanutbutter

Caroline's Cookies Monster Mash Cookie

A mash up of oatmeal, M&M’s, and peanut butter chips!

Monster Mash

Caroline's Cookies Pumpkin Spice Cookie

A soft pumpkin spiced cookie with a cream cheese frosting!

Pumpkin Spice

Caroline's Cookies Wedding Cake Cookie

A wedding cake cookie topped with a wedding cake glaze. This cookie is for wedding cake lovers!

Wedding Cake

Caroline's Cookies Samoa Cookie

Our take on the iconic Girl Scout cookie is our classic dough base with plenty of chocolate, coconut, and caramel! 

Samoa

Caroline's Cookies Reese's Chip Cookie

Classic cookie dough base has peanut butter chips and Reese’s peanut butter cups mixed in! It’s topped with melty peanut butter chocolate!

Reese's Chip

Caroline's Cookies Rainbow Crunch Cookie

A sugar cookie mixed with fruity pebble bits, rolled in Fruity Pebbles, and topped with a marshmallow buttercream!

Rainbow Crunch

Caroline's Cookies Biscoff King Cake

Our original king cake cookie topped with a Biscoff frosting and drizzle of cookie butter.

Biscoff King Cake

Caroline's Cookies French Toast Cookie

Maple cinnamon cookie that's rolled in cinnamon sugar and topped with a maple glaze, powdered sugar, and a French toast cereal!

French Toast

Caroline's Cookies Oreo Swirl

This cookie is rolled up with layers of buttery-Oreo goodness And topped with a cookies and cream cheese frosting! 

Oreo Swirl

Caroline's Cookies Mint Oreo Cookie

Chocolate chip cookie with mint Oreos!

Mint Oreo

Caroline's Cookies Nutella Stuffed Cookie

Our classic cookie stuffed with Nutella and rolled in graham crackers!

Nutella Stuffed

Caroline's Cookies Lucky Treat Cookie

A vanilla cookie with marshmallows and white chocolate chips, rolled in lucky charms cereal, and topped with marshmallow buttercream!

Lucky Treat

Caroline's Cookies King Cake Cookie

Our take on a classic cinnamon king cake with a vanilla glaze and Mardi Gras sprinkles!

King Cake

Caroline's Cookies Everything Brownie Cookie

A brownie cookie with a little bit of sweet and a little bit of salty: pretzels, potato chips, mini marshmallows, and mini M&M’s!

Everything Brownie

Caroline's Cookies Blueberry Crumble Cookie

Our classic cookie dough base with blueberries mixed throughout and topped with a light cinnamon crumble!

Blueberry Crumble

Caroline's Cookies Oatmeal Cadburry Egg Cookie

An oatmeal cookie with crushed up Cadbury eggs mixed throughout!

Oatmeal Cadbury Egg

Caroline's Cookies Lava Cake Coookie

Chocolate cookie filled with a gooey fudge center and sprinkled with a powdered sugar topping!

Lava Cake

Caroline's Cookies Cosmic Brownie Cookie

Brownie cookie topped with a chocolate ganache and sprinkles with rainbow coated chocolates!

Cosmic Brownie

Caroline's Cookies Brownie Siundae Cookie

Brownie cookie topped with caramel, 3 scoops of whipped cream frosting, chocolate syrup, sprinkles, and a cherry on top!

Brownie Sundae

Caroline's Cookies Worms in Dirt Cookie

Chocolate & Oreo cookie stuffed with a whipped chocolate center & topped with a gummy worm!

Worms in Dirt

Caroline's Cookies Biscoff Cookie

This cookie has white chocolate chips and bits of Biscoff mixed in and stuffed with a cookie butter center!

Biscoff

Caroline's Cookies Lemon Cookie

A lemon cookie topped with a lemon glaze and a slice of fresh lemon.

Lemon Cookie

Caroline's Cookies White Chocolate Cookie

A vanilla bean cookie with sprinkles mixed in & topped with a white chocolate ganache!

White Chocolate Vanilla

Caroline's Cookies S'mores

Chocolate chip cookie with graham crackers mixed in and stuffed with a marshmallow center!

S'mores

Caroline's Cookies Customer's Cookie

White chocolate chips cookie rolled in birthday cake Oreos, sprinkles, and mini marshmallows! It’s topped with a birthday cake Oreo buttercream!

Customer's Cookie

Caroline's Cookies Strawberry Pop-Tart Cookie

A sweet vanilla based cookie stuffed with local Noni's strawberry preserves.

Strawberry Pop-Tart

Caroline's Cookies Strawberry Crunch Cookie

A strawberry flavored cookie inspired by one of our childhood favorite ice cream bars!

Strawberry Crunch

bottom of page